ERC Research Papers

Cost Effective Defence

Published October 2006
By Lewis Page

Britain’s military is in crisis; under-equipped, undermanned, undersupplied and severely overstretched. Spending is not matching aspirations and there is an emerging consensus that this must be addressed. But what is the most intelligent way to apportion those funds in terms of costs versus capabilities?

Key Points:

The Economic Research Council, Britain’s oldest economic think-tank, has commissioned Lewis Page, author of “Lions, Donkeys and Dinosaurs – waste and blundering in the Armed Forces” to explore how the UK could radically reorganise its Armed Forces within the existing budget to finally move them beyond their redundant Cold War footing. Page explains in detail what equipment and capabilities needs to be bought and discarded and how funds can be found for a 50% pay rise for combat troops. Page lucidly illustrates how;;

Disproportionate resources in money and personnel are spent on:
 Anti-submarine warfare
 Surface-based defence against enemy air attack
 Overcoming enemy armoured forces using ground units
 Delivery of explosive strikes deep in enemy-held territory

Insufficient effort is being made in:
 Provision of deployable ground combat troops with a small logistical footprint
 Utility/transport helicopters
 Both heavy and light military air transports
 Sea-based aviation of every type

Page finished by making detailed reccomendations for:
 Savings – 7 areas that could be cut
 Spending – 9 areas that need resource
 Cost-neutral improvements – 11



Members can download this publication here.



Non-members can purchase ERC publications via Paypal.  Please select the title and format (where available) of the publication you wish to order from the drop-down menu below.

 If ordering a paper copy, please allow up to 5 working days for delivery.  If ordering a digital copy, it will be emailed to you as soon as possible following payment (usually within 1 working day).

Delivery Method
Electronic Copy£10.00 GBP
Paper Copy£12.50 GBP
Energy Policy: Which Way for the UK?
Aqua Brittania
Digest of Energy Statistics 2008
New Nuclear Build in the UK
Playing with Monetary Fire
Creative Destruction in the Music Industry
Cost Effective Defence
New Economics of Energy Security
Recharging the Nation


Other Publications

The full list to purchase research papers from the archives, and their paper and electronic availabilities, is below.

Research Paper Name Paper Electronic
Energy Policy: Which Way for the UK? Y Y
Aqua Britannia! Y Y
The Essential Guide to EU Quangos 2009 N Y
The Digest of Energy Statistics 2008 Y Y
New Nuclear Build in the UK – The Criteria for Delivery Y Y
Playing with Monetary Fire Y Y
The Spectre at the Economic Feast N N
Cracks in the Foundations? N Y
Creative Destruction in the Music Industry – The Way Ahead Y Y
Cost Effective Defence Y Y
The New Economics of Energy Security Y Y
The Essential Guide to British Quangos 2005 N N
Electrifying Britain – forward with Coal, Gas or Nuclear? N Y
Family Structure and Economic Outcomes Y N
Recharging The Nation Y Y
Identity and Development N Y
Forward with the Euro and the Pound N Y
The Deadweight State N Y
VAT: The Unacceptable Face of Taxation? N Y


For older publications, please see our Historical Archive.

Posted by ercouncil